Skip to content
Photonworld
The dark side of the universe

Das Kernelement des CRESST Experiments detektiert sogar Teilchen, die mit Materie kaum interagieren Max-Planck-Institut für Physik

Feature

The dark side of the universe

Over the last centuries, astronomers have revealed many mysteries of the universe with the help of light. But since the 1930s, scientists discover more and more hints that the majority of the cosmos is hidden in darkness. It seems that roughly 85% of the universe are made of an — up to now unknown — kind of matter which neither absorbs nor emits light. Consequently, a direct observation with telescopes is not possible. But what is this Dark Matter made of? Why do scientists actually know of its existence if they cannot observe it directly? And are there possibilities and tools to reveal its secrets?

A picture taken 14 billion years ago

But not only statements about single objects can be made. Detecting light also allows taking insight into times shortly after the big bang and, thus, understanding the history of the entire cosmos. In its childhood, up to an age of 380.000 years, the universe was so hot and dense that protons and electrons could not build stable hydrogen atoms. This is because the term “hot” describes the existence of many high energetic photons (light particles) colliding with the other particles and destroying their bonds. On the other hand, the light was not able to propagate freely through space, because it was scattered or absorbed even after shortest distances. Only after the universe was cooled by expansion, it became transparent for the photons. The light that has been scattered at this moment for the last time ever is still flying through the universe. Since its emission, this light was not disturbed on its journey through space and time and still carries information about this early age of the cosmos. When detecting this so called cosmic microwave background here on earth, it is like looking at a picture taken 14 billion years ago. This picture proves, with stunning precision, the big bang theory, helping to understand both the large scale cosmology and the miniature world of elementary particle physics.

In particular, we learn something remarkable from this cosmic microwave background: despite the huge amount of knowledge about fundamental physics collected during the last centuries, we have to accept that all the known matter only plays a minor part in the whole mass inventory of the universe. There is something contributing substantially more mass to the cosmos and therefore affecting the evolution and the structure of the universe to a huge extend. At this point, we enter the field of dark matter physics …

Five times more dark matter than normal matter in the universe

There are many indications for the existence of dark matter. The core of all observations supporting the theory of dark matter is that there is far more mass and consequently more gravitational force of attraction than expected by counting all stars, galaxies and other matter. It can be learned, for example from cosmic microwave background and the distribution of galaxies in the universe, that the amount of normal matter would not be sufficient to build the existing large scale structures. Current measurements indicate that only approximately 15% of all matter in the universe is made up from particles already known.

Evidence on much smaller scale can be found by having a look at the distribution of the stellar rotational velocities in galaxy. Analogous to our own solar system where the planets spin around the sun, inside of a galaxy stars fly around a common galactic center. However, the time and length scales are a good deal larger than the ones in planetary systems. Our solar system, for example, takes 200 million years for one orbit around the Milky Way.

Of course, the velocity of an object depends on the distance to the gravitational center. The closer the object is to a huge mass, the faster it has to move to assure a stable orbit. The earth travels at a speed of more than 100.000 km/h around the sun. A bit less and it would slowly spiral into the sun, a bit more and it would drift away eventually leaving the planetary system. For comparison: Mercury, the planet closest to the sun, moves with more than 170.000 km/h. The same argument is valid for stars in galaxies. Stars farther away from the galactic center should move at a slower pace. But measurements of the velocities show, that beginning at a certain distance to the center, all stars have about the same velocity — no matter how far outside. Nevertheless, they are bound to our galaxy.

The explanation believed to be correct by the vast majority of physicists is the existence of dark matter. Then the velocities of the stars could be explained by additional dark matter distributed on large scale across the galaxies. Consequently, there would be more matter between the center of the galaxy and the stars farther outside than between the center and the stars close to it. Stars at the border of the galaxy would feel a bigger force due to the additional attractive mass and would not drift away, even at high velocities. In this case, all observations can be understood. But: what would this dark matter be?

Dark Matter: The usual suspects

A pragmatic approach would be to question if one has really counted all of the matter in the universe correctly. Because not seeing them with telescopes does not necessarily mean that no burnt-out stars or non-luminescent planets from normal matter hide somewhere. One also speaks of so called MACHOs — Massive Compact Halo Objects — that do not emit light by their own, but could contribute enough mass to the galaxy to solve the problem. For example, only shortly scientists recognized a distortion in the movement of trans-Neptunian objects, indicating the existence of a ninth planet in our system. This planet we also cannot see, although its mass has an influence on its surrounding. Unfortunately, the theory of MACHOs being a solution to the dark matter problem had to be discarded. There is a method to estimate the number and the mass of these MACHOs: In case a MACHO gets between Earth and a star or galaxy, one would encounter a small variation in the brightness of the luminous object. It turned out that scientists should see a lot more of these events than they actually do to explain all of the dark matter with MACHOs. So, we have to look for something different.

One major hint on the nature of dark matter is provided by the cosmic microwave background from which we can see that dark matter must not consist of electrons and protons. If it would, the picture taken from the early stage of the universe would look totally different. Physicists can derive from the microwave background that particles must have been responsible for structure formation in the cosmos that had no interaction with each other — except for gravity — and thus were allowed to move unaffected by electromagnetic forces. But electrons and protons have existed as free particles in the first 380.000 years and their charge would have had huge influence on their behavior. Something different must have existed, which predetermined the basic gravitational structure of the universe. Protons and electrons mostly reacted to the existent gravitational force of these masses.

And in fact there already is a particle with parameters expected for dark matter: The Neutrino. Is this the particle solving the dark matter problem?

In the standard model of particle physics the neutrino is the fourth particle — besides electron, proton and neutron. Each time neutrons and protons are converted into each other, for example after nuclear fission or in nuclear fusion processes, neutrinos are produced. The idea to introduce neutrinos came up in 1930 as solution to a fundamental problem, when scientists encountered a violation of the laws of conservation of energy and momentum in processes of the weak interaction, and in the 1960s, their existence was experimentally confirmed. They are electrically neutral and can only communicate with other particles via gravitation or the weak interaction — perfectly fitting the requirements to be dark matter.

The drawback is: neutrinos have a very low mass. The mass of all neutrinos in the universe is not enough to explain the huge attraction and, as a consequence of their low mass, they are moving nearly with the speed of light. Particles with such a high velocity cannot be an anchor for the formation of a universe in which matter clumps to galaxies and galaxy clusters.

At the end, none of the known particles remains as dark matter candidate. But scientists have the tools to make one step further into this new field of physics.

Tracking dark matter

The current physicists expect that dark matter will turn out as an electrically neutral and, in comparison to the familiar particles, relatively heavy particle. The particles are bound to galaxies only interacting with other matter via gravitation and undisturbed by the electromagnetic force. They are present everywhere and also pass through the earth in high numbers without being noticed.

One attempt to find a final solution of the dark matter problem is made beneath the Italian mountain Gran Sasso. In a cave, scientists have built a laboratory shielded from cosmic and atmospheric radiation. Here the so called CRESST experiment is located.

“With our detectors, we try to directly measure dark matter particles”, Dr. Achim Gütlein from the institute of high-energy physics of the Austrian Academy of Sciences explains, who is a member of the international CRESST collaboration. CRESST is an acronym for “Cryogenic Rare Event Search With Superconducting Thermometers” and thus is not only the name but also a short description of the experiment. “The whole experiment can be equipped with up to 36 detector modules which can be separately read out. These are made of CaWO4 crystals with a mass of up to 300 g each. When a dark matter particle hits an atomic core inside our crystals, a vibration in the lattice — in other words heat — is produced. This heat is measured with highly sensitive superconducting thermometers.”

In addition to the heat, light is produced in such an event. Achim Gütlein declares: “In case other cosmic radiation or natural radioactivity enters our experimental setup, it may also lead to a nuclear recoil and produce heat. We can only distinguish between these events and the ones induced by dark matter particles by looking at the relative amount of the heat and light signals.” Of course, the heat produced by a single particle hitting a nucleus is very small. Because of this, one has to take care to reduce all lattice vibrations disturbing the measurement. This is done by cooling the experiment to a temperature below 20 mK — only 0.02 degree above absolute zero (which is at minus 273.15° Celsius).

It is a natural property of dark matter to interact very little with other matter. Of course, this complicates the desired detection, because the events will be very rare. Achim Gütlein says: ”Up to now, we have not discovered dark matter particles. But our detector is so sensitive that it would be enough evidence if only ten dark matter events would induce a signal in our detector per year.” It is a very familiar rule in natural science that even measuring no signal can be an interesting result. This way, theories can be tested and discarded and the parameter space for dark matter is further limited. “We still have the hope to achieve a direct measurement of dark matter after further increasing the sensitivity of our detectors”, says Achim Gütlein.

And so CRESST and all the other experiments in the world will continue their quest on finding the elusive dark matter. But so far, the secret of dark matter remains one of the biggest mysteries of modern physics.

Everything we see in the universe consists of only three particles: protons, neutrons and electrons. They are the basis to create stars, planets and even complex life on earth. An important result of this is that everything is made up of electrically charged particles. And charged particles are able to interact with light and consequently form matter that emits, scatters or absorbs light. This light serves as messenger of information about its source, the physical processes involved, and the history of our universe. The first statement is, of course: there are stars. As trivial as this may seem, we solely know of this fact because light from the stars arrives at earth and we have the correct detectors — our eyes or sophisticated telescopes — to recognize this radiation. The movement of the planets and stars can be followed to learn a lot about Earths place in the cosmos. But there is much more to gain from light. A more detailed view reveals that there are some small gaps in the continuous spectrum of our sun. This eventually tells that stars are giant balls of hydrogen, which is burnt to helium and later on to heavy elements while producing energy. The age and the mass of individual stars can be deduced from the emitted spectrum and is even able to predict whether they will end their life as a supernova. This list of knowledge gained from the light could be vastly extended. But the central point to keep in mind is that most things we know about the objects in the universe is only based on the observation and the interpretation of the light from outer space.